I'll go with soccerboy's idea then...

As nebnebben suggested, I agree. There definitely should be a SM63 comp. Or maybe just a "General New Game" Comp since there have been a couple new games i think.

Yeah, I think its a good idea because it would encourage people to make sm63 levels and I already know a couple of people who would make levels if the comp was introduced. Step forward all how propose this motion.

I agree with nebnebben.

Do note that Jell created a Mario comp pretty much instantly.

Yeah, I saw it just after I posted.

do most of the people here celebrate halloween?
i think we should do an all game comp - halloween!
excluding mine due to the minecraft comp in existance already

No, I think it'd be good to include Minecraft, that way if MCers don't wish to enter one comp, they can enter the other comp. Do we usually reuse comp ideas though? Cuz a Halloween comp is the 1st recorded comp of the Interguild.

What? Can't be right...check some old themes (PCCA #5 and such)

Sorry, I was just going by the comp archives right here. That's the last one listed. You guys ran comps before that, but there are no records on the Interguild.

how many users that participated in that are still here and would be mad at the thought of reusing?

The halloween comp was the very first comp that the PCCA held. Up until then, I think all we had was a poll with recently made levels and the winner would become the featured cave.

Which you stole from the HATPCG...aaah, Trapped In The Dark.

I don't celebrate halloween, but I'm totally in approval of such comp.

THE SCARY COMP

Marks out of 5 for how terrifing it is
Marks out of 5 for the actual level